John try reluctant to obfuscate the problem also this much within the Sherlock’s exposure. John lets Sherlock trust he could be straight, but the guy never ever shuts you to definitely door entirely: strange decisions having a great heterosexual guy, however, positively reasonable to have a bisexual child which is shopping for a relationship which have Sherlock and you may expectations Sherlock you’ll changes his notice. Although John can’t ever knowingly say “I am not saying gay” in this earshot away from Sherlock, Sherlock does overhear John say that to help you Irene when you look at the An excellent Scandal from inside the Belgravia – and then John attempts to features a discussion about any of it having Sherlock, and that’s shut down.
Better, to begin with, Sherlock appeared to extremely dislike the very thought of John becoming attracted to help you him. It’s a good idea John manage simply big date female to store Sherlock away from getting the impact. Think about, John was ready to destroy individuals stay close Sherlock, therefore definitely he’d become happy to hide their sex as well. Together with, when the John attempted to date people they would suppose he had been finding Sherlock, but not unfairly. It creates probably the most feel getting John thus far ladies, in which he does not appear to have a problem with it. (No matter if, to get fair, that have John you can not sure.) It’s quite simple to possess bisexual individuals live heterosexual lives: most people are heterosexual and you may imagine most people are too, so heterosexual matchmaking ventures appear without the need to getting tried away.
But as to why wasn’t John already unlock about this, and just why do the guy obfuscate the situation to his sibling and you will Expenses Murray? Really, you can find tips so you can much more factors throughout these very early site records. John is known as a females man before getting mailed out so you can Afghanistan, and in The unmistakeable sign of Around three we have been exhibited the character away from Significant Sholto, one which John considerably admires and contains a number of the exact same unsociable qualities Sherlock features; maybe the caretaker from inside the John are keen on people that appear psychologically injured and you can skittish.
And make bull crap about the indisputable fact that John would be gay was not the most delicate environment they could features built if John planned to turn out
As well as in greater conditions, it would be not surprising when the John’s homosexual front stumbled on the fresh fore when he was at the fresh military and you may generally in the middle of men – and indeed, regarding the Manifestation of About three we’re going to get significant homosexual contacts to the armed forces, and you will Major Sholto in particular. As well as, the fresh new reveal often reinforce over and over again that gender is actually crucial that you John. If the John keeps one destination after all so you can men, it is not unrealistic to trust he’d act with it when you look at the a keen ecosystem in which there are couple offered lady.
The most telling procedure, not, would be the fact John’s listeners for these “I’m not homosexual” moments is not Sherlock, even even though Sherlock think John was hitting with the your in the first episode and individuals continuously suppose these are typically several
Just what exactly took place in the Afghanistan? We don’t understand, but it is not at all tough to speculate. Maybe John failed to get to act with it, and then he will not can identify. Possibly it was unrequited, and he feels unfortunate or bitter contemplating unsociable people. Perhaps it absolutely was requited and you will ended poorly. Maybe the guy http://datingranking.net/tr/minder-inceleme did operate inside it but you will find pressure so you’re able to ensure that it stays miracle and you can, which have just returned in the battle, he’s not very sure tips begin getting open throughout the they provided his past profile and his awesome dated nearest and dearest becoming odd about it – perhaps not an unusual question for those who turn out afterwards inside lives, and Statement and Harry appear to discover the suggestion comedy. Or at least John told himself it absolutely was because ladies just weren’t readily available, however, he is beginning to realize maybe it was over you to. Perhaps he can choose female, and males need to be a gift. Perhaps the guy wishes youngsters; John looks happier enough when he discovers out-of Mary’s pregnancy when you look at the The sign of Three. It is really not anyway unusual to own bisexual guys for sex having people but only pursue dating having girls for that reason.